Menu of Mullin's Short Stop in Columbus, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

Mullin's Short Stop, nestled at 641 N Ludington St in Columbus, WI, is a quintessential summer destination for anyone craving classic American comfort food paired with rich, nostalgic ice cream treats. This charming ice cream shop and eatery, open seasonally, stands out despite its intentionally limited menu, proving that sometimes less truly is more.

The heart of Mullin's Short Stop lies in its simplicity and quality ingredients. The cheeseburger here is not just a menu item but an experience. From juicy, perfectly seasoned patties to fresh buns and crisp toppings, the cheeseburger consistently receives praise for its bold, satisfying flavors. Whether paired with crispy, golden onion rings or the acclaimed fries—both freshly made and cooked to perfection—it delivers a hearty, comforting meal that’s hard to beat. Customers like Grace Stonebrook and David Fude highlight the freshness and flavor balance, reflecting the kitchen’s dedication to quality.

On the sweeter side, the strawberry malt is a must-try signature treat. This classic malt blends creamy ice cream with a rich strawberry flavor, offering a nostalgic throwback that complements the savory offerings. The presence of local favorites like Sassy Cow ice cream adds a layer of authenticity and freshness that enhances the overall experience. Ice cream lovers, including Pamela S., find this spot irresistible, making it a perfect destination to cool down after a meal or simply enjoy a sweet outdoor treat.

While the menu may be "somewhat limited," as Wayne Carroll notes, every item feels intentional and lovingly prepared. The focus on quality over quantity means patrons enjoy fresh, flavorful bites without the fuss. The limited but well-curated ice cream flavors allow each scoop to shine rather than overwhelm.

What truly makes Mullin's Short Stop stand out is the ambiance. The outdoor seating provides a casual, relaxed vibe—ideal for summer evenings or quick weekend lunches. It's a place where simple, hearty foods meet classic, creamy desserts, creating a balanced dining experience that keeps customers coming back year after year.

In summary, Mullin's Short Stop delivers a compelling blend of savory and sweet, with standout cheeseburgers and strawberry malts that evoke comfort and satisfaction. Whether stopping by for a quick lunch or indulging in an ice cream cone under the open sky, this spot captures the essence of a beloved local summer tradition.